Orange criminals with no recent history of weapon shooting/threats crimes should not get their weapons confiscated when arrested as they did not commit any crimes related to weapons.
If the player found with no weapon license then the weapons should be confiscated even if they didn't commit any crimes with the weapons as they don't have a weapon license.
That seems to be fair to me as you shouldn't lose your weapons if you didn't even do crimes with them, but if you don't have a weapon license then you have to lose them for not having a weapon license.